America's hidden agenda in Syria's war
May 9, 2013
It was some six months ago that Syrian rebel commanders met US intelligence
officers in Jordan to discuss the status of the war and, the rebels hoped,
to secure supplies of the sophisticated weapons they need to overthrow
President Bashar Al Assad.
But according to one of the commanders present at the meeting, the Americans
were more interested in talking about Jabhat Al Nusra, the Al
Qaeda-affiliated group waging war on the Syrian regime than they were in
helping the rebels advance on Damascus.
The commander - a moderate Sunni and an influential rebel leader from
Damascus who said he has met intelligence operatives from Western and Arab
states - said the US officials were especially keen to obtain information
about the identities of Al Nusra insurgents and the locations of their
Then, by the rebel commander's account, the discussion took an unexpected
The Americans began discussing the possibility of drone strikes on Al Nusra
camps inside Syria and tried to enlist the rebels to fight their fellow
"The US intelligence officer said, 'We can train 30 of your fighters a
month, and we want you to fight Al Nusra'," the rebel commander recalled.
Opposition forces should be uniting against Mr Al Assad's more powerful and
better-equipped army, not waging war among themselves, the rebel commander
replied. The response from a senior US intelligence officer was blunt.
"I'm not going to lie to you. We'd prefer you fight Al Nusra now, and then
fight Assad's army. You should kill these Nusra people. We'll do it if you
don't," the rebel leader quoted the officer as saying.
What the commander says transpired in Jordan illustrates a dilemma that has
preoccupied, even paralysed, Syria's opposition and their international
supporters - how to deal with the expanding role of Islamic extremists in
the anti-Assad insurgency.
Other meetings with Western and Arab intelligence services have shown a
similar obsession with Al Nusra, the commander said.
"All anyone wants is hard information about Al Nusra, it seems to be all
they are really interested in. It's the most valuable commodity you can have
when dealing with these intelligence agencies," he said.
Jabhat Al Nusra has emerged as the most effective rebel force in Syria. The
fractured, poorly equipped rebels of the Free Syrian Army can ill-afford to
take the fight to Mr Al Assad's forces without Al Nusra, whose key leaders
are foreign veterans of the fighting that followed the US invasion of Iraq
The Obama administration classified Al Nusra as a terrorist organisation in
December, much to the annoyance of the opposition Syrian National Coalition
(SNC), which said the designation would only undermine the rebel campaign
and support Mr Al Assad's insistence that he is fighting "terrorists" rather
than a popular, pro-democracy uprising.
Two months ago, Al Nusra confirmed its link to Al Qaeda, publicly declaring
"allegiance" to the network's head, Ayman Al Zawahiri, and promised to
follow his orders.
Ever since, opposition political and military leaders, and their supporters
in Europe, the US and the Middle East, have been trying to work out how to
deal with the fact their allies on the battlefield are affiliated with the
group that carried out some of world's deadliest attacks on civilians.
As the rebels and their patrons abroad debate how to deal with Al Nusra,
questions persist over exactly how united Al Nusra is, and whether or not it
has adopted a new, less violent, strategy than that normally associated with
While key Al Nusra leaders are foreign fighters bloodied in Iraq's sectarian
civil war, a majority of the group's rank-and-file are Syrians, some of whom
have expressed dismay about the pledge to Al Qaeda.
On Saturday, another major hardline Islamic faction, Ahrar Al Sham, issued a
respectfully worded statement rebuking Al Nusra for openly siding with Al
Qaeda, saying it was divisive and would not help the rebels win - although
it supported the principle of a pan-Arab Islamic state.
Those within the moderate opposition advocating dialogue with Al Nusra warn
that merely dismissing all of its fighters as hard-core radicals is a
It also risks alienating the many ordinary Syrians in rebel-held areas who
have come to admire the group, with its reputation of honesty, discipline
and provision of humanitarian supplies to those in need.
"There are very localised differences between rebel groups, and Al Nusra is
no exception. Some are more extreme than others, and it's not right or
useful just to put them all together as being Al Qaeda," said a moderate,
Western-educated pro-democracy activist who has been involved in meetings
with Nusra fighters in northern Syria.
Syria's political future was discussed at the meetings, and Nusra members
were open to debate and discussion, and had shown interest in proposals
about democracy and safeguarding Syria's minority communities, activists
"When you actually sit down with them [Al Nusra], you realise they are not
what you thought and they also have to rethink their own preconceptions. We
had a meeting and it was very good and these young fighters were surprised
because they thought all people who supported democracy were atheists," the
activist said. "For those reasons, it's important to keep a dialogue going."
Another Assad opponent, a secular Syrian involved in organising armed groups
in Damascus, also warned against ignoring the differences within Al Nusra.
Comparing the situation in Syria to that in Afghanistan, he said the reach
of Al Qaeda had always been held in check because they were foreigners not
locals. The Americans, he said, made a mistake by waging war on the Taliban,
with whom the Afghan authorities are now trying to negotiate.
"I am worried about Islamic extremism, but I think we need to be smart in
how we handle it. Otherwise we'll make matters worse, not better," he said.
"In the end this should be a matter for Syrians to resolve, it's not for the
West to tell us who are terrorists and who are not."
The rebel commander who described meeting US intelligence officers in Jordan
said he had refused to give them any information about Al Nusra.
Although not a supporter of Al Qaeda's ideology, he said the Americans were
being too clumsy and would only undermine the revolt against Mr Al Assad.
"There are three strands of Al Nusra - the minority are serious Al Qaeda
people, some are just in for the glamour of fighting jihad and the majority
are ordinary Syrians who just want to save their country," he said.
Since that meeting the rebel commander has not bothered to talk to Western
or Arab intelligence agencies, despite what he described as frequent
invitations for more talks. Rather than wait for foreign governments to
supply weapons, his group has imported their own advanced explosives and
begun manufacturing their own munitions.
"They [foreign governments] are not fighting for the same things as us," he
said. "Syrians are fighting for our freedom, while they just want us to
bleed to death fighting each other."
Follow us: @TheNationalUAE on Twitter | thenational.ae on Facebook
(F)AIR USE NOTICE: All original content and/or articles and graphics in this
message are copyrighted, unless specifically noted otherwise. All rights to
these copyrighted items are reserved. Articles and graphics have been placed
within for educational and discussion purposes only, in compliance with
"Fair Use" criteria established in Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976.
The principle of "Fair Use" was established as law by Section 107 of The
Copyright Act of 1976. "Fair Use" legally eliminates the need to obtain
permission or pay royalties for the use of previously copyrighted materials
if the purposes of display include "criticism, comment, news reporting,
teaching, scholarship, and research." Section 107 establishes four criteria
for determining whether the use of a work in any particular case qualifies
as a "fair use". A work used does not necessarily have to satisfy all four
criteria to qualify as an instance of "fair use". Rather, "fair use" is
determined by the overall extent to which the cited work does or does not
substantially satisfy the criteria in their totality. If you wish to use
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner. For more information go to:
THIS DOCUMENT MAY CONTAIN COPYRIGHTED MATERIAL. COPYING AND DISSEMINATION IS
PROHIBITED WITHOUT PERMISSION OF THE COPYRIGHT OWNERS.