How Brown Moses exposed Syrian arms trafficking from his front room

 

How Brown Moses exposed Syrian arms trafficking from his front room

 

Leicester-based blogger's monitoring of weapons used in conflict has been

taken up by media and human rights groups

 

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/mar/21/frontroom-blogger-analyses-weapons-syria-frontline

 

 

Eliot Higgins, aka Brown Moses, encounters a new video from Syria from

matthew weaver on Vimeo.

 

Eliot Higgins has no need for a flak jacket, nor does he carry himself with

the bravado of a war reporter. As an unemployed finance and admin worker his

expertise lies in compiling spreadsheets, not dodging bullets. He has never

been near a war zone. But all that hasn't stopped him from breaking some of

the most important stories on the Syrian conflict in the last year.

 

His work on analysing Syrian weapons, which began as a hobby, is now

frequently cited by human rights groups and has led to questions in

parliament. Higgins' latest discovery of a new batch of Croatian weapons in

the hands of Syrian rebels appears to have blown the lid on a covert

international operation to arm the opposition.

 

And he's done it all, largely unpaid, from a laptop more than 3,000 miles

away from Damascus, in his front room in a Leicester suburb.

 

Behind the tulip-patterned lace curtains, among the discarded toys belonging

to his toddler daughter, a new video has just popped into his inbox. It

appears to shows Croatian weapons, believed to have been smuggled to Syria

with the collusion of the west, in the hands of jihadi fighters, who are

increasingly leading the fight against Bashar al-Assad's government.

 

Higgins' weapons-spotting eye is immediately drawn to two tubes next to a

large gun. The detail suggests that any US attempts to vet which groups get

such arms are failing. Pointing at the screen, Higgins says: "Those are

rocket pods for the M79 Osa Croatian rocket launcher. And what's even more

interesting is this YouTube channel belongs to Ansar al-Islam, which is a

jihadi organisation. That group shouldn't be getting those weapons."

 

Higgins, 34, has no training in weapons, human rights research or journalism

- he dropped out of a media studies course at university. But his work is

being taken up by everyone from Amnesty International to the New York Times.

 

He is amused to be referred to as a weapons expert. "Journalists assume I've

worked in the arms trade," he says, "But before the Arab spring I knew no

more about weapons that the average Xbox owner. I had no knowledge beyond

what I'd learned from Arnold Schwarzenegger and Rambo."

 

Higgins initially operated on chatrooms and comment threads under the

pseudonym Brown Moses. His online avatar - taken from one of Francis Bacon's

paintings of a screaming pope - was often the first to appear in the

comments section on the Guardian's daily Middle East live blog.

 

Each day he would do verbal battle below the line with online trolls,

conspiracy theorists and fellow Arab spring obsessives. The name Brown

Moses, taken from a Frank Zappa song, has led to confusion about his

identity.

 

"It makes some people think I'm black and Jewish - I've even been racially

abused. I've been accused of all sorts of things online: CIA, MI5, MI6,

Mossad, Bilderberg group."

 

Partly to avoid such suspicions, he no longer conceals his identity and has

emerged into the open, where he is being hailed as something of a pioneer.

 

The conflict in Syria has been extremely difficult and dangerous for

conventional media organisations to cover. But the slew of YouTube footage

from citizen journalists has opened up a new way of monitoring what's

happening for those such as Higgins who are dedicated and meticulous enough

to sift through it.

 

"Brown Moses is among the best out there when it comes to weapons monitoring

in Syria," says Peter Bouckaert, emergencies director at Human Rights Watch,

who worked with Higgins to document the use of cluster bombs in Syria. He

represents an important development in arms monitoring, which used to be the

domain of a few secretive specialists with access to the required and often

classified reference materials.

 

"He'd be the first to admit that he is obsessive compulsive in his attention

to details. He gets his facts right, and has become an indispensable

resource."

Eliot Higgins, blogger on syrian weapons Eliot Higgins at home.

 

The New York Times veteran war reporter CJ Chivers, author of The Gun: the

story of the AK47, says fellow journalists should be more honest about the

debt they owe to Higgins' Brown Moses blog. "Many people, whether they admit

or not, have been relying on that blog's daily labour to cull the

uncountable videos that circulate from the conflict," he says.

 

Chivers acknowledged that Higgins was on to the Croatian arms story weeks

before the New York Times. He and Higgins then worked together to develop

the story, with Chivers rooting out extra details about how the weapons were

financed.

 

In a blogpost about the genesis of the report, Chivers wrote: "Thank you,

Eliot, for your patience, and your fine eye, and for creating an opportunity

for merging new and old forms of reporting into a fresh look at recent

events."

 

Higgins goes through about 450 YouTube channels from Syria every evening.

The list includes uploaded footage from activists, rebel brigades and

Islamist groups, as well as from Assad supporters and state TV footage. "If

EastEnders isn't on I get straight on the laptop. On a good night when

nothing much has been posted, it will take me an hour and a half, but I've

been looking more closely recently."

 

Recent activist footage claimed to show the remains of a Chinese-made

cluster bomb at the scene of a bombing. Drawing on his online network of

fellow weapons-spotters and translators, Higgins established that it was in

fact a bicycle pump. "If I started putting out rubbish I'd know about it

pretty quickly, because of the audience that follows me," he says.

 

"The success of the blog feeds the compulsion," Higgins says. "If I had the

chance I do it for 16 hours a day. When I'm sat on a bus I'll be checking

Twitter looking for footage of planes being shot down. When cluster bombs

were first used I couldn't sleep. It was about midnight and I saw this video

of these bomblets spilt on the floor with their casings. I had to research

it. You have to be first and you have to be right."

 

Since then, Higgins has put together a database of 491 videos of cluster

bombs being used across Syria, together with map references and details of

the type of weapons used.

 

He has had more time to do this since being made redundant from his day job

last October. The organisation he was working for lost a government contract

to house asylum seekers to the security firm G4S. "None of my jobs have been

relevant to the work I'm doing now," he says. "The closest I got to Syrians

was telling asylum seekers where they were being picked up. The advantage

I've got is time and the fact I've been going through them for a year or

so."

 

Higgins' wife's job behind the counter at the local post office helps pay

the bills. "My wife sees me doing all this work and thinks I should be

getting paid for it. But I'm doing it because I see stuff that isn't being

reported in the mainstream media and want to record it."

 

He says his approach is no substitute for traditional war reporting but it

can help tell the story. "This can't replace journalists on the ground," he

says. "They take amazing risks and do an incredible job. But this work can

direct them.

 

"I don't think many people would have picked up on Croatian weapons in Deraa

because there weren't journalists in that area. It may never have been

noticed. It was only because I was on the lookout for interesting looking

rocket launchers."

 

What we have learned about Syrian weapons via Brown Moses

 

. Cluster bombs were first spotted by Higgins in summer of 2012 and used

extensively used from October. The Syrian government denies they exist in

Syria, but Higgins has developed a database of almost 500 videos documenting

the use of cluster bombs, which are banned in most countries.

 

. Reports of DIY barrel bombs being thrown out of helicopters were initially

dismissed as "baloney" by a Russian military expert. Extensive and clear

footage unearthed by Higgins suggests otherwise.

 

. The proliferation of shoulder-launched heat-seeking missiles known as

Manpads. Most recently Higgins has documented Chinese-made FN6 Manpads in

the hands of rebels fighting around Aleppo.

 

. A cache of weapons from the former Yugoslavia was first noticed by Higgins

at the start of this year in the hands of rebel groups fighting in the

southern province of Deraa. The weapons were financed by Saudi Arabia with

the knowledge of the US, subsequent reports alleged.

 

==========================================

(F)AIR USE NOTICE: All original content and/or articles and graphics in this

message are copyrighted, unless specifically noted otherwise. All rights to

these copyrighted items are reserved. Articles and graphics have been placed

within for educational and discussion purposes only, in compliance with

"Fair Use" criteria established in Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976.

The principle of "Fair Use" was established as law by Section 107 of The

Copyright Act of 1976. "Fair Use" legally eliminates the need to obtain

permission or pay royalties for the use of previously copyrighted materials

if the purposes of display include "criticism, comment, news reporting,

teaching, scholarship, and research." Section 107 establishes four criteria

for determining whether the use of a work in any particular case qualifies

as a "fair use". A work used does not necessarily have to satisfy all four

criteria to qualify as an instance of "fair use". Rather, "fair use" is

determined by the overall extent to which the cited work does or does not

substantially satisfy the criteria in their totality. If you wish to use

copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you

must obtain permission from the copyright owner. For more information go to:

http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml

 

THIS DOCUMENT MAY CONTAIN COPYRIGHTED MATERIAL. COPYING AND DISSEMINATION IS

PROHIBITED WITHOUT PERMISSION OF THE COPYRIGHT OWNERS.